Job, in the midst of his suffering, stated:
Job 1:21 – and said: "Naked I came from my mother's womb, and naked I will depart. The Lord gave and the Lord has taken away; may the name of the Lord be praised."
This passage raises several questions.
† All questions could simply be answered by saying – this is a true statement – we have a Sovereign God who controls all things
† Questions arise when we say that not all things quoted in the Bible are good thing or God things – for instance:
o The story of David, Bathsheba, and Uriah in 2 Samuel 11 doesn’t suggest that we should all desire other men’s wives (even if we have the power to do so).
† Although God is Sovereign and is the supreme ruler, to assume that God gives and God takes away, as a general truth for God leads to many unsettling circumstances.
o Is it God who takes a baby in crib death?
o Is it God who takes a baby in a miscarriage?
o Is it God who takes a baby through abortion?
o Is it God who causes a child to be bore handicapped?
o And so on…
Where as it is true that we came into the world with nothing and will leave it just the same – maybe some fancy clothes on our body in our casket – but none-the-less – without anything. It may not be a truism that God gave it all and took it all away. Our free will has played into the equation and the free will of others as well.
Because Job felt all he had came from God and if God wanted to, He could take it all away, doesn’t mean a universal truth is that God gives and God takes away. Our free will many times takes away our health, the life of others, and even at times impacts the lives of those around us.